An old sentence is not an oath
By Marc Winn

In 2014, I wrote that publishing my beliefs would force me to live up to them.
I can see the appeal. There would be a sentence on the internet, with my name attached, making it harder to quietly pretend I had never thought it. A small arrangement between the person who wrote something and the person who would have to wake up the next morning.
But there is a trap in that arrangement. What happens when the sentence stops being true?
I don't mean a promise to another person. If I have agreed to turn up, changing my philosophy is a fairly poor excuse for leaving someone standing outside a café. Other people should not have to pay for my freedom to keep becoming someone else.
I mean a belief. An explanation that seemed to fit. A way of seeing something that made the world a little more intelligible, until something happened that it couldn't explain.
Writing gives such things a peculiar solidity. What was provisional in my head arrives on the page looking quite sure of itself. The hesitation disappears. A title goes on top. Someone shares it. Before long, an idea I was trying out can look like a position I am employed to defend.
Perhaps that is one reason being wrong can feel more expensive in public. There is an old version of me still making the case.
I don't want to disown him. He was trying to understand something. I would rather not make him the permanent editor of everything I am allowed to understand next.
There is a difference between abandoning a belief because it has become inconvenient and changing it because I can no longer honestly hold it. I don't have a neat test that always tells me which I am doing. The temptation to call avoidance growth is real. So is the temptation to call fear of changing integrity.
Perhaps living up to what I write also means being willing to say where it no longer fits. Keeping the old words visible, without requiring my life to become their supporting evidence.
I started the blog partly to hold myself accountable. I still want that. I am less sure that accountability means remaining recognisable to every sentence I have ever written.
I would like to leave the next sentence a little room.
Reader responses
Be the first to respond.